(96 customer reviews)

Hand Made Farmhouse Extra Tasty Cheddar Cheese

Kept between 12 and 18 months. This Cheddar gets extremely tasty and is considered one of the best handmade cheddars in the country.




You will not find cheese like this in the supermarket! This is Farmhouse cheddar at its finest. The distinct extra mature nutty flavour of our Extra Tasty Cheddar will transport you back through the ages to rural Somerset. Back to the good old days of hay making in the sun, slowly ploughing fields with your trusty horse and hand milking the herd using only a bucket and a three legged stool. Traditionally matured for 12 to 18 months this cheddar packs a punch while still retaining a smooth texture. A firm favourite with the locals, this cheese also has an international reputation with Gold awards at the ‘World Cheese Awards’ and more recently, a Gold at ‘The Global Cheese Awards 2016’. Take this opportunity to tuck into a slice of history.

Additional information


200g, 400g, 800g

96 reviews for Hand Made Farmhouse Extra Tasty Cheddar Cheese

  1. Karen h. (verified owner)

    I regularly order 2 blocks but they has got to be the best so far. The flavour was amazing and so strong. I think my next order will be sooner this time as it is so moorish

  2. Ashley Baker (verified owner)

    I love cheese – and for me there is NO comparison to this cheese; just the ultimate – thank you for making it!!! Literally tell everyone about this cheese 🙂 !!!

  3. Anonymous (verified owner)

    Excellent service and product. Won’t eat any other cheddar now. I have been spilt

  4. Ruqaiyah (verified owner)

  5. Philip Donald (verified owner)

    Great cheese

  6. David H. (verified owner)

    Real tasty cheddar

  7. Mike Crossman (verified owner)

    Best cheddar clue is in the name

  8. James Sproat (verified owner)

    The best cheese you can buy in my view. Creamy with a lingering after taste, just how I like it.
    Great and fast service. I will be coming back for more orders.

  9. Kim Stygall (verified owner)

    Unfortunately, we received 2x Extra Tasty 800g and 1x Fiery Fred 800g instead of 3x Extra Tasty. Was there a reason for this?

  10. Michael Kelly (verified owner)

    Haven’t tried it yet but the service was good.

  11. COLIN FIELDING (verified owner)

    Wonderful Cheese

  12. ANDREW BIRD (verified owner)

  13. David (verified owner)

  14. Neil P. (verified owner)

    Great produce and service

  15. Anonymous (verified owner)

    OMG This is the best cheese EVER. I will never go back to an ordinary cheddar again. It is costing a fortune to deliver but worth it, the only problem is that I am buy it in large quantities to save on postage but just end up eating more of it. I may end up having to move closer to the Farm😁

  16. Megan (verified owner)

  17. James Sproat (verified owner)

    The Handmade Farmhouse Extra Tasty is a unique cheese in the best sense of the word. Like it says it is extremely tasty, creamy beyond any cheese I’ve tasted, it melts in your mouth and lingers there. It truly is the finest of cheeses in my view. I will certainly be ordering again very soon!
    I can’t recommend this cheese and farm business highly enough.

  18. robert horwood (verified owner)

    same as above a very tasty cheddar

  19. Andrew Frost (verified owner)

  20. William Hughes (verified owner)

    Says it all on the label – ‘extra tasty’ – and it certainly is. Five Star. 👍

  21. John C. (verified owner)

  22. Phil L. (verified owner)

    Excellent flavour and most enjoyable to eat

  23. David Kocfelda (verified owner)

  24. Joanne C. (verified owner)

    Good strong cheddar without those nasty salt crystals.

  25. Andrew Frost (verified owner)

    As always, fantastic cheese and speedy delivery, thank you. “I’ll be back”

  26. David Ponting (verified owner)

    Fine cheese, very tasty.

  27. Anonymous (verified owner)

    Bit too sour for my liking, but it’s expected from a mature cheese

  28. Colin J. (verified owner)

    The BEST cheddar!!

  29. Nigel B. (verified owner)

    Terrific cheddar from an outstanding maker.

  30. Philip Read (verified owner)

  31. ian lewis (verified owner)

    Nice taste and texture

  32. William Clark (verified owner)

  33. robert horwood (verified owner)

    the usual tasty cheese

  34. Andrew Frost (verified owner)

    Fantastic as usual. Another order being placed soon!!

  35. Anonymous (verified owner)

    Really lovely cheese, I love strong cheese and you just can’t buy it in the shops, this one ticks all the boxes, love it. Easy to order and very quick delivery, knocked one star off just because of the postage costs, otherwise excellent!

  36. David Ponting (verified owner)

    Great cheese, quick delivery, really pleased.

  37. Elisa (verified owner)

    Beautiful beautiful flavour I would buy more. But the postage puts me off
    Rather expensive needs looking at.

  38. Deborah (verified owner)

    Great cheese, very fast service only gripe is the delivery cost.

  39. Sue Mizon (verified owner)

  40. Stephen S. (verified owner)

  41. Sue Watkins (verified owner)

  42. Nigel D. (verified owner)

  43. Anonymous (verified owner)

  44. Jarrett Newman (verified owner)

  45. robert horwood (verified owner)

    another great tasting cheese

  46. Paul Robinson (verified owner)

    Lovely cheese

  47. Angela Lodge (verified owner)

    The best of the bunch.

  48. Anonymous (verified owner)

  49. Barbara Stratton (verified owner)

  50. Anonymous (verified owner)

  51. ian lewis (verified owner)

    a nice texture, and great taste

  52. Paul (verified owner)

    This is lovely as well

  53. Paul (verified owner)

    Lovely, as expected

  54. Barbara Stratton (verified owner)

  55. Andrew Frost (verified owner)

    Best cheddar by far!!

  56. ian lewis (verified owner)

    A superb cheese, nice texture, and great taste

  57. Paul R. (verified owner)

    Lovely, as it says, tasty plus.

  58. Martin (verified owner)

    Delicious strong cheddar taste

  59. Chris B. (verified owner)

    Very good with lots of flavour

  60. Nathan P. (verified owner)

    Excellent flavour and feel. Really enjoying.

  61. Katherine (verified owner)

  62. Chantal (verified owner)

  63. Andrew Frost (verified owner)

    Always lovely cheese, and your order/delivery process is fast efficient and awesome!
    My next order will be coming soon.

  64. ian lewis (verified owner)

    a very nice taste and texture

  65. Jennifer (verified owner)

    Speedy and safe delivery of a gorgeous flavoursome cheddar

  66. Noleen Whiles (verified owner)

  67. Jim Canning (verified owner)

    We found this to be sufficiently strong for normal use.

  68. Dominique F. (verified owner)

    This cheddar is litterally melting in your mouth! Excellent

  69. Paul Robinson (verified owner)

    Same comment, always lovely

  70. stuart ferris (verified owner)

  71. Daron Rogers (verified owner)

    Excellent cheese!

  72. Michael Barnes (verified owner)

    I first found this cheese at the Maidenhead Farmers Market. My all time favourite – you can’t get better.

  73. Robert H. (verified owner)

  74. PY Streiff

    The best cheddar I’ve ever had. I tasted it and bought it last Sunday at Queens Park Farmers Market London. Ce fromage est une tuerie. Avis aux Français qui liraient ce message, il faut vraiment le goûter. C’est un goût incroyable. I order it again from France today. Thank you !

  75. C D Jones (verified owner)

  76. Robert Horwood (verified owner)

    second best to fiery freds

  77. g butchers (verified owner)

    Divine divine
    Will definitely be ordering again

  78. Colin Jones (verified owner)

    I wish there was higher than 5 – may well be the best Cheddar I have ever had (cheeseaholic), will definitely be buying again!!

  79. brenda docker (verified owner)

    Got it husband for are 32th wedding anniversary . He loves your cheese.

  80. ROBERT HORWOOD (verified owner)

    wonderfull tasty chedder cheese and the delivery was brilliant thank you

  81. Anonymous (verified owner)

    Really tasty cheese. Only gave four stars because I got no confirmation email and had to telephone to confirm the order had been received. Friendly service though.

  82. Toby Coulson (verified owner)

  83. Geoff M. (verified owner)

    some of the best Cheddar I’ve ever tasted

  84. Alan Boulter (verified owner)

    Will definitely order more 🙂

  85. ROBERT HORWOOD (verified owner)

    promt service and very tasty cheese

  86. ROBERT HORWOOD (verified owner)

    a wondefull tasty cheese

  87. Michael Pearce (verified owner)

    Definitely my favourite of the two. Very strong flavour with no unpleasant after taste that one gets with “mass produced” cheese. Perfect companion to crusty bread, pickled onion and home made tomato chutney washed down with locally produced cider. Heaven on a plate. Well done Mr/Mrs/Ms cheesemaker

  88. ROBERT HORWOOD (verified owner)

    if you like a tasty chedder, this is another good cheese

  89. Jeff Williams (verified owner)

    Lovely tasting cheese. Great aftertaste.

  90. ROBERT HORWOOD (verified owner)

    A very tasty cheese

  91. Christina M. (verified owner)

  92. Angela Wells (verified owner)

    So much tastier than supermarket cheese!

  93. ROBERT HORWOOD (verified owner)

    the hand made is allso a very tasty cheddar

  94. Robin Boyes (verified owner)

    If cheese alone was to be scored, then 10 out of 5 would represent an unfair score. This cheese not only has a taste of its own but can be judged as one of Britain’s best, the French really should be given a chance of the experience. The only reason for the lack of a point is the delivery, which I hasten to add was nothing of the cheesemakers or farmers doing. This is the kind of cheese one wishes to tell and show everyone that you have found, one for the cheeseboard, permanently.

  95. Robert Horwood (verified owner)

    wonderfull service and brilliant cheese

  96. Neil Shopland (verified owner)

Add a review

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.